Redwall - The Siege [DVD]

**Editorial Review of Redwall DVD:** The Redwall DVD has elicited a range of responses from viewers, particularly among those familiar with the original book series. Overall, while some customers appreciate the video quality and see value in the adaptation, the Consensus seems to lean towards disappointment—especially among dedicated fans of Brian Jacques' beloved novels. Many reviews share a common thread of criticism regarding the artistic liberties taken in the adaptation process, including omitted story elements, character alterations, and changes to critical events. Several reviewers noted that only the first four episodes of Matthias's story arc are included, which some found limiting, particularly given the abrupt stop after a significant encounter with the Sparrow King. This episodic structure raised eyebrows among fans expecting a more complete viewing experience in one go. While some parents reported that their children enjoyed the content, which likely speaks to its accessibility for younger audiences, avid readers voiced strong disapproval. The adaptation's divergence from the source material, including the downplaying of beloved characters like Basil Stag Hair and an altered plot that introduced elements not present in the books, was particularly disappointing for many. Issues such as censorship, evident through the omission of darker themes and more intense scenes, were also highlighted, raising concerns about the integrity of the original story being preserved. Despite these criticisms, the film's animation style received some praise, although mixed with remarks on the reproduction quality appearing less favorable—specifically, instances of black and white viewing that contradicted promotional material. Ultimately, Redwall seems better suited for a younger audience or those unfamiliar with the books, while die-hard fans might want to steer clear to preserve the integrity of the original tale. **Pros and Cons:** **